Denis Poroy - AP
almost 2 years ago: San Diego Padres David Eckstein reacts after having gatorade poured over him by teammates after a baseball game against the San Francisco Giants Monday, April 19, 2010 in San Diego. Eckstein hit a walk-off home run in the tenth inning to give the Padres a 3-2 win. (AP Photo/Denis Poroy)
In light of David Eckstein's almost, but not quite, retirement, it's only fitting that we decide where he fits on the list of the all time scrappiest San Diego Padres.
It's not an insignificant honor to be included on a list of scrappy players. Among the numerous criteria for being considered for this definitive list, a scrappy player must:
One is disqualified from this list if they have ever been referred to as a "natural talent" or "physically gifted".
WITHOUT FURTHER ADO...
5. David Eckstein - David Eckstein would rank higher on this list except for the fact that he so wanted to be referred to as "scrappy" that it made it even more painful and embarrassing to watch him play for us. Also, his wife is really pretty and talented and it becomes almost impossible to believe that he's relying solely on scrap. Like, I believe you're scrappy, David Eckstein, but no amount of scrap is letting you marry that far above your head. He does get bonus points for excessively waving his bat during his stance as if to say, "I am so scrappy and hopped up on caffeine, I literally can not hold still for two seconds."
4. Chris Denorfia - Chris Denorfia almost doesn't make this list because he is not shorter than 6 feet and yet he fits almost all of the criteria. He put together one of the finest defensive seasons in Padres history in 2010 and yet he's known as the bad fielder who would have to fall down and dive to stop a softly hit ball that lands directly in front of him. Chris Denorfia has been known to make spectacular diving catches while catching a cold. People often watch him play and wonder if he must be getting paid to be trying so hard. Like, jeez dude. Settle down a bit.
3. Chris Gomez - Some would have you believe that Chris Gomez was one of the worst short stops to ever wear a major league uniform and they'd have some pretty good statistical evidence. And yet there he was, seemingly year after year playing for the Padres. If he was your favorite Padre during his time here, nobody would've blamed you at the time, but now you would attribute that to youth and not knowing anything about anything.
2. Eric Owens - I sometimes think that Eric Owens is actually still active in the major leagues somewhere and has simply taken his scrappiness to the level of wearing a fat suit, impersonating an overweight DH from the Dominican. During his brief stint with the Padres, Eric Owens was never known to not take an extra base. Devilishly quick on the base paths, one could not be blamed for mistaking him for an elf that makes shoes for needy cobblers as opposed to a professional baseball player. His straight steal of home is still remembered in Padres folklore as it happened against Brett Tomko, a right handed pitcher, with a left handed hitter at-bat, meaning everybody in the world had a perfectly clear view of Eric Owens except for anybody that could've done anything to prevent it. In the process of that particular steal, Owens also managed to distract Tomko so badly that the pitcher rolled his ankle during the pitch and was forced to leave the game.
1. Tim Flannery - While many of today's younger Padres fans remember Tim Flannery as the overenthusiastic third base coach for our San Diego Padres and/or a decent folk singer who would smoke weed at Rugburns shows and hang out with Steve Poltz, he is and will be known as the San Diego Padres true scrapper. A cloud of dirt would follow Tim Flannery around the beaches of San Diego, warding off panhandlers and gypsies. As a third base coach for the team, he tried to impart his scrappiness onto other players by never actually putting up a stop sign. Legend has it that after becoming a third base coach, he had his right arm replaced with a propeller from a retired Navy fighter plane from WWII.
4 recs | 91 comments
Ray Kroc's Ghost Fully Supports This Post
Ray Kroc’s Ghost Seal Of Approval
It’s Scrap-tacular.
hs619 - January 24, 2012
But...
…what about Bip?
hs619 - January 24, 2012
Bip actually had legit speed though.
Jsn L - January 24, 2012
oh man
i forgot about those giveaway Eric Owens t-shirts that had fake dirt and grass on them.
kevintheoman - January 24, 2012
I tried to find a pic of that...
…but I failed miserably.
hs619 - January 24, 2012
I think my mother still has hers. She LOVED EO.
Darklighter - January 24, 2012
I tried to back you up on that
and it’s amazing how googling Eric Owens hardly returns any images of Eric Owens, much less a grass-stained t-shirt.
scout1222 - January 24, 2012
Before I got to your list...
the first player that crossed my mind was Eric Owens. I was at the game when he stole home. Unfortunately I was more intersted in the beer and dog I was downing and didn’t see him take off. I stood up in time to see him cross the plate. I celebrated by finishing the dog and grabbing another beer.
Jsn L - January 24, 2012
Eric Owens
Was my favorite player on those teams. I think I may be one of the only people outside of his immediate family to have an Eric Owens signed baseball prominently displayed in my house
padres8 - January 24, 2012
John "Flash" Flaherty...
is one I always considered to be a scrappy player.
Jsn L - January 24, 2012
No way in hell does anybody beat Eric Owens on this list
This list is a SHAM!
matthewverygood - January 24, 2012
Eric Owens was so scrappy...
… his uniform was covered in dirt before the first pitch.
… he could reach base on a strikeout.
… he could get grass stains from artificial turf.
… he hit for the cycle with two broken arms.
Darklighter - January 24, 2012
And that homerun for the cycle was an inside-the-parker
sdchicken - January 24, 2012
I remember a game
in the 1997 Season, when Chris Gomez single handedly destroyed the Giants with a 2 HR game. And that relief pitcher… Brueske got us out of a jam.
1997 disappointing season, but a couple awesome high notes like this one.
MrDanielX - January 24, 2012
Under "criteria" you forgot
Must be a white guy.
vivajackmurphy - January 24, 2012
“Be a player who tries much harder than everybody else to make up for some deficiency. The most obvious being size or a lack of baseball talent”
SeeAnFrockOh - January 24, 2012
yeah but in the media
only white athletes really get credit for having heart over athletic ability. there are plenty of black and latin athletes that play much higher than their ability level but when was the last time you heard ray rice, deion branch, ben wallace, joakim noah, bill hall, or omar vizquel referred to as scrappy?
heck, jerry hairston hasn’t even been mentioned in this thread and he had scraps on scraps on scraps on scraps.
iheartyourfart - January 26, 2012
Muggsy Bogues
Dex - January 26, 2012
Denorfia - glass arm
Seriously impaired throw. When he plays left field watch how he one- or two-hops the ball in to Headley.
Yes he can steal home.
http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=17261797
glyonax - January 24, 2012 via iPhone app
Scrappy!
If it was easy for him, he wouldn’t be scrappy.
Dex - January 24, 2012
Nobody had more heart and scrap than Li'l Joey.
TheThinGwynn - January 24, 2012
I really should have seen this coming.
Darklighter - January 24, 2012
haha
justdave - January 25, 2012
Joey Cora was not only scrappy,he was also good at getting stabbed.
http://articles.latimes.com/1986-06-23/sports/sp-19996_1_joey-cora
KevinMcReynolds - January 26, 2012
If you’re interested, here are a few other factoids about the great one.
…and if that wasn’t a Joey O.D., here’s some sappiness about His Scrappiness.
TheThinGwynn - January 26, 2012
Tim Flannery knew how to take a pitch, and by take a pitch, I mean take a pitch on the shoulder, in order to get on base/advance a runner.
Flan Man rules the universe. Great post. Thanks for the memories of Flannery greatness.
jeremy.lassen - January 24, 2012
that's true
If there was somebody who knew how to get hit by a pitch it was Flannery.
Dex - January 24, 2012
almost Biggio-esque
justdave - January 25, 2012
Flannery was a great Padre. His songwriting leaves a lot to be desired. A LOT!
KevinMcReynolds - January 26, 2012
Scrappy?
seems like you added a few that don’t yet belong while leaving off a couple. First, I remeber when Benito got his wrist broken and the backup hs already played, so the scrappiest and funniest sight I ever saw at a Padres game was Joey Cora in catchers gear behind the plate. And let’s look back the the early years when we had two scrappy ballplayers or maybe three (only Gaston, Cannizaro and Colbert had any real talent) Larry Stahl was the scrappiest of the 3 followed by Dave Campbell and Ivan Murrell, all 3 would be considered for this list except that there were seldom more than 5000 fans at those games to see them play or even remember them.
Eric Owens fans obviously did not see Tim Flannery surf the infield at the Murph during his heyday. No one in a Padres uni to date has ever been scrappier.
lawrencenall@yahoo.com - January 24, 2012
A lot of players were scrappy
But even the Padres knew who the scrappiest was. And they honored him with a “Flan” Appreciation Night. Anyone remember that? I still have the pin.
cubbuster - January 24, 2012 via mobile
You were there for that?!?!
Oh, man, I am SO jealous.
TheThinGwynn - January 24, 2012
I was young. my grandparents had season tickets
Oddly enough, Tim Flannery became somewhat of a family friend for a time as he was friends with my mothers husband at the time. So, we got to have him over for dinner… I remember showing him that pin (it must have been about three years after the famed Flan Appreciation Night) and having him sign it. I told all of my friends at school, but most of them didnt remember the name…. And i wanted to punch them.
cubbuster - January 24, 2012 via mobile
I was replying to lawrencenall about seeing Joey catch...
…but, whoa, that’s awesome that you had Flan over for dinner!
TheThinGwynn - January 25, 2012
I ran into Chris Gomez in the Encinitas Hollywood Video circa 1997.
We were the only two customers picking out videos. I don’t know what movies he picked out, but Rudy was probably one of them.
SeeAnFrockOh - January 24, 2012
good that you recognized him
because he looks like he works at a hollywood video
iheartyourfart - January 24, 2012
I saw him when I was a vendor at the murph...
Getting my paycheck one day. He was a lot taller than I thought he would be. I said hi, and he said hello. And then u said " your chris gomez" and he said “yup” and that was that.
cubbuster - January 24, 2012 via mobile
Hollywood-what-now?
Wonko - January 26, 2012
I would give both of my left nuts for video of Eric Owens stealing home.
(don’t laugh. it’s a medical condition.)
Johnny UT - January 24, 2012
My recollection is that Channel 4 barely got it on camera.
He was almost home by the time they realized what was happening.
Darklighter - January 24, 2012
Mark Kotsay (2)
friarinchicago - January 24, 2012
He wasn't with us for long, but does Luis Durango deserve an honorable mention?
He couldn’t hit, he couldn’t field, he couldn’t throw, but he could run and steal with the best. Plus, he has a killer smile…
sdchicken - January 24, 2012
We're looking for scrappiest, not crappiest.
TheThinGwynn - January 24, 2012
Can't have scrap without crap.
padmadfan - January 25, 2012
And the "S" in front of it just stands for "Super"
Hence, Super Crap
sdchicken - January 25, 2012
he was waaaay too fast to be scrappy
he may be one of the fastest individuals I have ever seen.
He just couldn’t do anything else.
Ron Mexico - January 25, 2012
gotta question chris gomez's scrappiness
i think you gotta hand it over to damian jackson or wiki gonzalez before gomez. gomez was awful but i wouldn’t say he got to play everyday because of scrap but rather bochy thought the fact that he made very few errors qualified him to be an everyday shortstop.
iheartyourfart - January 24, 2012
damian was only scrappy when marry multiple wives.
Ron Mexico - January 25, 2012
multiple wives?
How about Al Martin?
Nater Tater - January 25, 2012
yeah, that's the ticket, Al Martin
Ron Mexico - January 26, 2012
Wiki Gonzalez was scrappy when it came to finding edible parts of animals
I heard he could digest hair.
Dex - January 25, 2012
I think The Norf should get bonus scrap points for being the backup backup catcher.
TheThinGwynn - January 24, 2012
One day, he's gonna get his shot to show off his skills
He’ll get behind the plate in the 14th inning of a game and throw out like 5 guys. It’s gonna happen.
Friar Fever - January 25, 2012
i can just see him diving to block a pitch
that goes right down the pipe, causing the ball to nail the umpire right in the junk. Preferably its one of the umpires we hate,
Nater Tater - January 25, 2012
infinite points
iheartyourfart - January 25, 2012
Will Cunane
Was definitely the scrappiest pitcher we ever had hands down. He deserves an honorable mention.
cubbuster - January 25, 2012 via mobile
see i think its Josh Spence
by a landslide.
The guys throws 46mph and gets strike-outs. His uniform is WAY too big for him. He embodies scrappiness.
justdave - January 25, 2012
the problem with his uniform, if they made it tight enough for his body frame, it would only be one piece of fabric.
Little known fact, but his uniform is actually spandex.
Ron Mexico - January 25, 2012
It's also footy pajamas at night.
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
Can pitchers be scrappy?
The idea of a scrappy pitcher doesn’t quite jibe in my head. Like what’s the equivalent of taking an extra base or getting your uniform dirty to a pitcher?
Dex - January 25, 2012
Pitchers are Crafty
Ron Mexico - January 25, 2012
I don't know...
I consider Tim Stauffer more scrappy than crafty.
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
steve
iheartyourfart - January 25, 2012
fucking
iheartyourfart - January 25, 2012
trachsel
iheartyourfart - January 25, 2012
You mean Steve "Eight" Trachsel?
That dude took forever to throw the ball.
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
Actually, no... I've decided
There’s been exactly one scrappy pitcher in the history of baseball and that’s Kit Keller and no self respecting man would aspire to be a plain faced, skinny red-head, never gonna find herself a man after the war.
Other than Kit Keller, there’s no such thing as a scrappy pitcher.
Dex - January 25, 2012
Who the hell voted you the decider of all things scrappy!?!?!
Oh, yeah…now I remember. I know…I know…I’m banned, right?
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
Hey, I'm plain faced, skinny and currently red-headed.
Oh, you said self respecting. Nevermind, carry on.
TheThinGwynn - January 25, 2012
After wartime though
I bet you find yourself a man and make scrappy little babies. Kit’s destined to be an old maid, owns a fruit stand off the highway selling strawberries and making pie.
Dex - January 25, 2012
Andy Ashby, and Sterling Hitchcock
Were both scrappy pitchers. Slightly above average… but every so often would sweat and will themselves to wins over Randy Johnson, and Greg Maddux.
MrDanielX - January 25, 2012
Both those guys were naturals and physically gifted
good at baseball too.
jbox - January 26, 2012
Brian Tollberg.
Guy had a straight 87 MPH fastball and a slurvey curveball. He had no stuff whatsoever, but he went out and smoked, mirrored and snotballed his way through every start. It was like watching a midget on a highwire get pelted with snowballs. You were just like “How is he not falling? How is he doing this?”
Scapiness, my friend. Pure scrapiness.
padmadfan - January 25, 2012
Paul Mcanulty
soulSD - January 25, 2012 via Android app
they said "scrappy"
not “tubba tubba tubba tubba tubba tubba tubba tubba”
justdave - January 25, 2012
Can anyone who wants to be scrappy, be scrappy?
I see it as like trying to be hip. The mere fact that you are trying for it, means that you can never be it.
field39 - January 25, 2012
Hip? Don't you mean 'cool' old timer?
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
field39 - January 25, 2012
Scrappy Doo is scrappy
Jsn L - January 25, 2012
I hate this.
rec’d.
Axion - January 25, 2012
Mike Darr was pretty scrappy
He was one of my favorites before he passed away.
All Things SD - January 25, 2012
Mike Darr could hit, had some skillz
he just had no lift on the ball.
Ron Mexico - January 25, 2012
Marcus Giles was pretty scrappy. If you don't think so you should ask his wife.
KevinMcReynolds - January 25, 2012
i think the juice precludes scrappiness
Dex - January 25, 2012
Even if Marcus Giles was at one point scrappy
he never was with the Padres.
jbox - January 26, 2012
okay , funny how I see Marcus Giles
and then Chris Young in comments. I may be remembering it wrong, but my image of Marcus in my head is trying to get between CY and Lee and being flicked away like a pesky little fly.
Nater Tater - January 26, 2012
if that is wrong, I don't want to know what is right
Ron Mexico - January 27, 2012
Chris Young..
for wanting to scrap it with D Lee which wouldve ended with a Lee broken jaw and faceplant
Duke Street Kings - January 26, 2012
No Craig Lefferts?
Craig Lefferts was the scrappiest Padre in history. No MLB player has ever ran back and forth from the pitchers mound to the dugout as fast as Craig. He would of smoked Heath Bell in a race from the bullpen to the mound. He also was the one who finally plunked Pascual Perez – resulting in the biggest baseball fight in history.
Dave Drevecky - January 30, 2012
Kurt Bevacqua
His name should have been Kurt Scrapacqua. Played from 1971-85 and really only had 1 great game; ‘84 World Series game 2 when he hit that 3-run shot off Petry. Otherwise mostly known for getting under Tommy Lasorda’s skin, riding the pine and being the 1975 Topps Bubblegum Champ. Scrappy.
AceWrigley - January 30, 2012
Scrappy players
do not blow kisses to the crowd while rounding the bases, after hitting a World Series home run.
field39 - January 30, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Gaslamp Ball to post a comment.