When Yelp was first really hitting popular strides a few years back, Arthur Frommer, the founder of the famous travel guides, critiqued the "critics" both in an editorial and in several interviews on Rick Steves' travel show on NPR.
The basic premise is this... While everybody is entitled to their opinion, somebody who offers a truly expert opinion will always run circles around a social media site.On the one hand, you have a critic who's done research to the tune of tasting and trying every restaurant in a given area and is able to compare that to restaurants in surrounding areas or even other parts of the world while educating and infusing his or her culinary knowledge combined with insights into the true value of what it is you are about to eat. On the other hand, you have your next door neighbor who's been to Phoenix twice and managed to find the VERY BEST BARBECUE IN THE SOUTHWEST and is insistent upon the fact based on the fact that he had one meal at Phil's and he discovered that he doesn't like BBQ sauce, but watch out, because at $15 a plate it be WAY more expensive than what BBQ is worth, but hey they serve High Life.
So, I agree with Arthur Frommer and I take every piece of advice on Yelp with a grain of salt.
And yet... That does not stop me from asking you what Mentor has asked of us... To help him find the "best" foods in San Diego.
Today's topic.... What is the best taco in San Diego?
To be sure, it is just about impossible to find a bad taco in San Diego. You have to try really hard. Like you have to be going to Del Taco and then letting their #1 meal sit and go stale before you find a bad taco and even then, it's better than what you'll find at a taco shop in Missouri.
On my personal short list:
Like seriously, as long as it's shredded beef or deep fried fish or sufficiently fatty carnitas, how far off could you possibly be from a great taco in San Diego? San Diego is a place where you could have 4 taco shops on a single block and all of them have a line out the door at lunch time with every single person talking about how this one is their favorite taco shop ever.
IT SHOULD NOT BE HARD TO SERVE A FANTASTIC TACO AT PETCO PARK.
So let's help Mentor figure out what he should be emulating.
I also will also take a moment of silence to remember El Asadero Market, formerly on El Cajon Blvd in the college area. The best tacos in San Diego and for no good reason, they just poof vanished while I wasn't looking. Seriously, you don't even know. Don't mess around. Five street tacos there and you're in heaven. Also mighty fine carne asada burritos.
2 recs | 115 comments
Rudy's on Stephens in Solana
hands down the best carne asada TJ street tacos I’ve ever had.
derntootin - January 12, 2012
Ah man. We were really close to trying this recently
Dex - January 12, 2012
Rudy's is good
and Bongiorno’s pizza is there too – which makes this a little corner of food heaven
Hormel - January 12, 2012
I used to live down the street from Rudy's
It was way too tempting.
SolanaFan - January 12, 2012
How could you not add...
Tacos El gordo to the list?! An institution to the greater San Diego area.
will61589 - January 12, 2012
Mentioned this is hamburger thread. Tacos el gordo is bomb dizzle.
soulSD - January 12, 2012 via Android app
Trust me... I've forgotten plenty of taco shops
Dex - January 12, 2012
Lolita's at the ballpark
I’m never disappointed when I leave there. Carne Asada tacos or burritos. Carne Asada chips. California burrito. Always fantastic.
AIChief - January 12, 2012
Try the...
Two in One. See my post below for whats inside.
will61589 - January 12, 2012
Seconding this
They are gooooood.
bcline760 - January 12, 2012
Mama Testa
Potato Tacos are tops for me. El Indio rolled tacos close second.
Frozen_Pizza - January 12, 2012
Hell yes.
Mama Testa is the best. I love the fish tacos and the carnitas and the steamed tacos and… well, the whole damn menu. And the salsa bar!
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
Those Mama Testa radio commercials really turned me off on that place
They always have some actor playing the really ignorant gringo, it was almost racist. Like you’re going to insult me and then ask for my business?
jbox - January 12, 2012
I've never heard their radio commercials.
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
Never heard those
but they can’t be much worse than the Sombrero’s “we cater too” speedy gonzales voice.
Frozen_Pizza - January 12, 2012
Im going to put on my hipster glasses and say “overrated”.
soulSD - January 12, 2012 via Android app
perhaps
after bobby flay makes a visit, a place can become overrated pretty quickly.
Frozen_Pizza - January 12, 2012
I am a native San Diegan
Mama Testa Fish Tacos are the best things I have ever eaten. Along with some of their chipotle hot sauce.
MrDanielX - January 12, 2012
Blue Water Seafood Grill
Not quite authentic but some of the freshest fish tacos in San Diego and not fried
TheAxManCometh - January 12, 2012
If it's not fried, it's not the best fish taco.
But Blue Water is really good. Their crab and artichoke dip is heaven in a bread bowl.
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
Used to love that place til it gave me food poisioning
Sad part is I still miss it despite them giving me the heaves.
athletics68 - January 12, 2012
I'm calling user error.
Richard Wade - January 12, 2012 via iPhone app
Sadly not
I think it was just a bad shrimp cocktail
athletics68 - January 12, 2012
How about best taco/burrito combination?
Hands down goes to the Lolitas two in one burrito. If you have never tried it, do so. Its a Carne Asada, Guac, 2x Cheese burrito with two rolled tacos stuffed inside. Heavenly.
will61589 - January 12, 2012
Mexican Fiesta in financial block downtown. Only problem is the shack is so small and always takes 30 mins to get food.
soulSD - January 12, 2012 via Android app
damnit not meant to be reply. SBN app is not fresh.
soulSD - January 12, 2012 via Android app
that sounds amazing
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
jesu cristo
The Kipper - January 12, 2012 via mobile
As another reference
Ducksnorts had their Unofficial Guide to San Diego Taco shops. It may be a bit out of date though.
jbox - January 12, 2012
The very first shop listed...
El Asadero… So sad…
Dex - January 12, 2012
I can't trust a list with sombrero's on it
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
Taco Bell's 12 taco box
Is a game changer.
Mad_Villain - January 12, 2012
Yesenia's in Carmel Mountain
Their carne asada burritos are delish as well as their tacos. I think I might make them today’s lunch.
bcline760 - January 12, 2012
Where is that?
AIChief - January 12, 2012
I mean where in Carmel Mountain?
AIChief - January 12, 2012
On Carmel Mountain Rd.
It’s in the same complex as Home Depot, Pat & Oscars, and Wings & Things. In fact, it’s right next to W&T.
bcline760 - January 12, 2012
That was going to be my guess. I'll give it a go.
AIChief - January 12, 2012
I've been there plenty of times
but never knew that’s what it’s called.
Mad_Villain - January 12, 2012 via Android app
Jalapeños
How would you compare Ysenia’s to Jalapeños (down by Rite Aid and SuperCuts)?
glyonax - January 12, 2012 via iPhone app
Haven't been
I should make it a point to go just to have some kind of comparison.
bcline760 - January 12, 2012
Jalapenos
Stellar carne asada chips and breakfast burritos.
AIChief - January 12, 2012
That's a bingo.
Yesenia’s is one of the best.
StrangeBroP25 - January 12, 2012
Rubios Fish Tacos are tops IMO
Since the brought back the Alaskan polluck. But for regular tacos Im fond of either El Indio, or Miguels (specifically the one in Pt Loma).
athletics68 - January 12, 2012
It always feels weird to praise a big chain
but yeah, rubio’s does have some good fish tacos
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
When I read yelp
I always read the lowest rated scores first. The low rating scores are the most telling as to if the score is BS or not. I’ve seen people rate burger places 1 star for not offering chicken sandwiches. I’ve seen someone give 1 star to a tiny taco shop for not accepting debit/credit cards.
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
tacos are for wimps...
Carne Asada fries from Roberto’s…
I ALWAYS make sure I get this at least once when I come into town (living outside of CA has its disadvantages).
Zen Blade - January 12, 2012
I'm not that into tacos
so I have no real opinions on that.
Rodrigo’s in PQ is my favorite for carne asada fries/chips. It’s probably mostly high school nostalgia though.
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
another thing, +1 to fish tacos needing to be deep fried
I don’t even know how wahoo’s is able to advertise themselves as a fish taco place.
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
And in corn tortillas!
Don’t get me wrong, I love the salmon taco at Tin Fish, but it’s a salmon filet with a side of tortilla.
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
agree
Although it doesn’t bother me as much as the grilled fish does.
I get quite condescending, arrogant, and combatitive when someone tells me they ate a fish taco with grilled fish. It’s okay to like grilled fish placed in a tortilla; just don’t call it a “fish taco”.
kevintheoman - January 12, 2012
Y'know, you can even call it a taco.
But it’s not a fish taco. It’s a mahi mahi taco, or whatever. I mean, you wouldn’t say you had fish and chips if the fish wasn’t fried, right?
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
grody
The Kipper - January 12, 2012 via mobile
grody
The Kipper - January 12, 2012 via mobile
Carnitas Uruapan
matthewverygood - January 12, 2012
Jose’s Taco Depot
Rudy’s is good, too.
Jorge’s Mexicatessen – is chicken soup a good ballpark food?
Axion - January 12, 2012
El Azteca over in La Mesa.
Awesome tacos, and even more amazing burritos, not to mention massive. Seriously, their breakfast burrito is almost a meal for 2.
surferfromSD619 - January 12, 2012
Azteca is my spot
Been going there for over 10 years. I get a burrito everytime I’m back in town.
matthewverygood - January 12, 2012
Cotixan by the DMV in Clairemont.
justdave - January 12, 2012
Ooh, that's close to home
I’ve yet to try them.
scout1222 - January 12, 2012
There's another in Poway. Big-ass portions.
StrangeBroP25 - January 12, 2012
or Los Dos in La Jolla
justdave - January 12, 2012
los dos
carne asada torta. delicious.
derntootin - January 12, 2012
or Taco Surf on Mission in PB
justdave - January 12, 2012
Market International 2000 3rd Ave Chula Vista
2nd choice is any Cotixan
glyonax - January 12, 2012 via iPhone app
tacos
My list
JV mexican food bay park
las brasas mission hills
el cuervo hillcrest
El zarape (both locations)university heights and north park
senor panchos San marcos These are possibly the best street/mini tacos I’ve had. with real guac and three grilled green onions and a deep fried serrano pepper on the side. I knew they where the best when I finished them and just sat there going wow
These are all traditional Mexican food restaurants with good, fresh, well prepared food at a decent price.
Sorry I don’t eat tacos at trendy places
bobmcd - January 12, 2012
i want to superimpose these over that this post
justdave - January 12, 2012
El Zarape
That place is excellent. I couldn’t think of the name. Kept googling El Zapato and finding mexican shoes.
Dex - January 12, 2012
Their burritos are better than their tacos.
MrDanielX - January 12, 2012
I'll third El Zarape
I love their rolled tacos. Real meat inside with now rice. Great guac and white cheese. The only thing better would be to use cotija cheese as well. Their House (Chicken Mole) burrito is fantastic.
fairweather - January 12, 2012
I love their fish tacos
It’s almost like tempura the way they cook it up. Soooooo good.
Dex - January 12, 2012
Yes.
Another vote for El Zarape. This place is my favorite. Great rolled tacos and their House Burrito (Chicken Mole) always hits the spot.
fairweather - January 12, 2012
Ugh. Sorry for the double post
My internet sucks at work.
fairweather - January 12, 2012
El Zarape is pretty good...
not to complain but their menu is TOO BIG. Make it simple stupid…ya know?
BryanHarvey'sMoustache - January 14, 2012
Senor Panchos is the train one, right? I haven’t been since it changed names, but I’ve had the tacos. Vote seconded for street tacos.
Axion - January 12, 2012
I used to live by the Senor Pancho's near SDSU.
It was our go-to simply because it was in walking distance and open late and we were usually too lazy to cross the street to go to Trujillo’s.
Don’t order the California burrito or carne asada chips.
jodes0405 - January 13, 2012
Grossest. Taco Shop. Evar.
Sam (sdsuaztec4) - January 15, 2012
Shame on all of you for talking about tacos when the ownership of the Padres is in doubt!!!
Besides, it’s pretty hard to fcuk up a taco, so any corner mexican joint works.
Jsn L - January 12, 2012
Fidel's in Solana Beach and Carlsbad
Bomb. One of the best hot sauces I’ve had.
And a chalupa? Really?
Bigworm8 - January 12, 2012
Someone's a local!
Because you still call it “Fidel’s” despite it’s now called “Norté”. Don’t worry, I still say “Tom Giblin’s”.
bcline760 - January 12, 2012
Wait, it's not Fidel's anymore?
Darklighter - January 12, 2012
I'm so local, I didn't even know the name changed.
Bigworm8 - January 12, 2012
And I was just there two weeks ago.
Bigworm8 - January 12, 2012
i didn't either
justdave - January 12, 2012
me either
I will always call it Fidel’s. Eden Gardens, Holmes! Anyone remember Bluebird cafe down there? It was my first meal after I lost my virginity.
The Kipper - January 12, 2012 via mobile
Have you ever had a chalupa?
It’s amazing.
Dex - January 12, 2012
Steak Chalupa's are great.
Only think I will eat at TAco Hell.
MrDanielX - January 12, 2012
LOVE FIDEL'S.
jodes0405 - January 13, 2012
South Beach
South Beach Bar and Grill for fish tacos. Easily the best in town. PB Fish shop a close second.
Imissburritos - January 12, 2012
yes!
fish tacos here are the best
derntootin - January 12, 2012
is it still good?
i thought it was delicious like 12 years ago when I lived round there. all these posts are making me hungry. and envious.
hbar - January 12, 2012
I love
Karina’s in Leucadia
I had no idea they have 5 other locations
Hormel - January 12, 2012
Said it in the Burger thread
but Nicos in OB is the best. Can’t go wrong with the breakfast buritto or carnitas plate.
mrbarneydangles - January 12, 2012
Los Panchos TJ Tacos
Jack in the Box Tacos
Tio Leo’s Tacos
Del Taco 39 cent tacos
Padres_Hobo - January 12, 2012
Tio Leos Carne Asada tacos are sensational
And their shredded beef tacos as well.
MrDanielX - January 12, 2012
JITP tacos
are not real tacos….maybe not even real food
but they are yummy
Hormel - January 12, 2012
Everyone always raves about Rosaritos #7 in lemon grove
TheVinylCrocodile - January 12, 2012
Fins has amazing Shrimp Tacos.
MrDanielX - January 12, 2012
Fins?
It’s been over a decade since I lived in San Diego but I thought that all the Fins closed a while back.
Drakos - January 12, 2012
McGregor's
I don’t know why McGregor’s in Mission Valley has such great fish tacos but they are absolutely amazing. And they’re only $1.50 too during happy hour.
bryan. - January 12, 2012
Trujillos
Sam (sdsuaztec4) - January 12, 2012
You would.
jodes0405 - January 13, 2012
God, I need to get downtown for a Mexican food tour
Poway is pretty barren unless you get into the surrounding areas, or the south end of town… friggin’ suburbanites.
Tio Leo’s— their happy-hour street tacos are the best. Don’t know if they’re still on the menu, I haven’t been in a while, but I used to order them with every meal.
The two major ‘Bertos joints in my neck of the woods are Aibertos and Albertos (now called El Armando’s, but the menu is the same)— aka the Brick and the Barn. Best bet at both places are probably burritos (they’re huge at Aibertos), though the rolled tacos deserve praise as well.
El Ranchito is extremely popular, though I’ve never been able to see why. Nothing there is especially outstanding— I suppose because it’s close to the high school.
Lienzo Charro and El Comal are also worth mentioning, but as they’re sit-down restaurants it’s unlikely they’ll end up at the ballpark.
StrangeBroP25 - January 12, 2012
Forget everyone else's brand
They need to sell Friar Tacos, Friar burritos and bowls of Friar verde. They need to brand it and own it.
field39 - January 12, 2012
Las Olas in Cardiff.
Also Fidel’s and Especial Norte.
SeeAnFrockOh - January 13, 2012
Las Olas in Carlsbad too.
I like it, but I never go there because I always just go to Fidel’s.
jodes0405 - January 13, 2012
Las Olas
is my go to huevos rancheros gig on sunday after a night of too much drinkin’
Hormel - January 13, 2012
I heard a story
That someone ordered a taco in France and the waiter came back with a piece of toast and two sardines on it.
jbox - January 13, 2012
Props to will61589
for mentioning Tacos al Gordo….
Al Gordo and Tacos el Paisa in Logan Heights are my favorite joints for authentic tacos; hell, they have the word “taco” in their name….
ProfessorAl - January 13, 2012
YES to El Gordo and El Paisa
Tacos El Gordo is the best true “street taco”, and I love the mysterious giant vat of simmering beef parts….. if you are at the Palm Ave location get the crazy loaded fires with Al Pastor and Carne Asada piled on top… mmmmmm……
For those of you by the ballpark, venture a wee bit east to 25th and Imperial and GO TO Tacos El Paisa. You whiteys who are scared of the barrio be comforted, the police station is across the street. Excellent everything but the breakfast burritos and pollo asada are standouts.
Also props to La Posta in Hillcrest, maybe the best “generic taco shop” style place I know of. They have the best rolled tacos in town, perfectly crispy with tons of guacamole and the crumbly white cotija cheese.
EitanBomb - January 13, 2012
Bahia Don Bravo in La Jolla.
Beer-battered fish tacos. 99-cent street tacos. So good.
jodes0405 - January 13, 2012
OMG YES
First time I ever went there I got the Don Bravo Burrito since I figured ‘Well, it’s named after the place, so it has to be good right?"
Wasn’t just great, it was AWESOME.
surferfromSD619 - January 13, 2012
Don't live in SD but visit often...
I always head to El Zarape with my buddies. Also, some joint in the University Heights district called Rigoberto’s serves some greasy late night goodness if you’ve finished a six-pack on your own and think Mexican is a good idea.
BryanHarvey'sMoustache - January 14, 2012
Great recomendations, but here's one for ya
Liticker’s on Voltaire St in OB. Go there now. If it’s closed, just sit there and wait for it to open. You will not be disappointed.
Sixto - January 15, 2012
Anyplace that sells a California burrito.
RexTookMyStash - January 20, 2012
So, anywhere but Jack in the Box
Friar Fever - January 21, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Gaslamp Ball to post a comment.